Adapting to Student Uncertainty Improves Tutoring Dialogues
نویسندگان
چکیده
This study shows that affect-adaptive computer tutoring can significantly improve performance on learning efficiency and user satisfaction. We compare two different student uncertainty adaptations which were designed, implemented and evaluated in a controlled experiment using four versions of a wizarded spoken dialogue tutoring system: two adaptive systems used in two experimental conditions (basic and empirical), and two non-adaptive systems used in two control conditions (normal and random). In prior work we compared learning gains across the four systems; here we compare two other important performance metrics: learning efficiency and user satisfaction. We show that the basic adaptive system outperforms the normal (non-adaptive) and empirical (adaptive) systems in terms of learning efficiency. We also show that the empirical (adaptive) and random (non-adaptive) systems outperform the basic adaptive system in terms of user perception of tutor response quality. However, only the basic adaptive system shows a positive correlation between learning and user perception of decreased uncertainty.
منابع مشابه
The Role of Initiative in Tutorial Dialogue
This work is the first systematic investigation of initiative in human-human tutorial dialogue. We studied initiative management in two dialogue strategies: didactic tutoring and Socratic tutoring. We hypothesized that didactic tutoring would be mostly tutor-initiative while Socratic tutoring would be mixedinitiative, and that more student initiative would lead to more learning (i.e., task succ...
متن کاملPredicting Student Emotions in Computer-Human Tutoring Dialogues
We examine the utility of speech and lexical features for predicting student emotions in computerhuman spoken tutoring dialogues. We first annotate student turns for negative, neutral, positive and mixed emotions. We then extract acoustic-prosodic features from the speech signal, and lexical items from the transcribed or recognized speech. We compare the results of machine learning experiments ...
متن کاملRecognizing student emotions and attitudes on the basis of utterances in spoken tutoring dialogues with both human and computer tutors
While human tutors respond to both what a student says and to how the student says it, most tutorial dialogue systems cannot detect the student emotions and attitudes underlying an utterance. We present an empirical study investigating the feasibility of recognizing student state in two corpora of spoken tutoring dialogues, one with a human tutor, and one with a computer tutor. We first annotat...
متن کاملUncertainty Corpus: Resource to Study User Affect in Complex Spoken Dialogue Systems
We present a corpus of spoken dialogues between students and an adaptive Wizard-of-Oz tutoring system, in which student uncertainty was manually annotated in real-time. We detail the corpus contents, including speech files, transcripts, annotations, and log files, and we discuss possible future uses by the computational linguistics community as a novel resource for studying naturally occurring ...
متن کاملAnnotating Student Emotional States in Spoken Tutoring Dialogues
We present an annotation scheme for student emotions in tutoring dialogues. Analyses of our scheme with respect to interannotator agreement and predictive accuracy indicate that our scheme is reliable in our domain, and that our emotion labels can be predicted with a high degree of accuracy. We discuss issues concerning the implementation of emotion prediction and adaptation in the computer tut...
متن کامل